I played football for Wales but the cladding scandal could bankrupt me


AI Summary Hide AI Generated Summary

The Cladding Crisis and its Impact

Brian Law, a former Welsh international footballer, is facing bankruptcy due to escalating costs associated with the remediation of flammable cladding on his buy-to-let flat in Birmingham. The initial service charge demand of £16,000 spiraled into £82,000 in debt, forcing him into voluntary repossession.

Financial Hardship

The article details the significant financial burden Law and his wife faced, including failed property sales and mounting debts, including mortgage payments, council tax, and service charges. Health issues further complicated their situation.

The Role of EWS1 Forms

The article points out the challenges homeowners face in obtaining EWS1 forms (external wall system), which are often required by banks for mortgages, further hindering property sales.

Impact of Grenfell Tower Fire

The Grenfell Tower fire of 2017 is mentioned as a catalyst, exposing widespread fire safety issues across the UK and highlighting the ongoing struggle for homeowners impacted by the cladding crisis.

Seeking Bankruptcy

Law is exploring bankruptcy as a solution to his insurmountable debt, a decision driven by the devastating financial consequences of the cladding scandal. This underscores the crisis’s wide-reaching effects on individuals and families.

Campaign Groups' Statements

Statements from campaign groups like Leasehold Knowledge Partnership and End Our Cladding Scandal emphasize the ongoing suffering of numerous individuals affected by the building safety scandal, highlighting the systemic issues and inadequate support.

Remus' Response

Remus, the managing firm, states that remediation work was completed but declines to comment on the specific case.

Sign in to unlock more AI features Sign in with Google

It was not until Brian Law received a £16,000 service charge demand for his buy-to-let that he realised the flat was wrapped in flammable cladding.

The former Welsh international footballer bought the flat in the Islington Gates development in Birmingham in 2005, after injury put an end to his career at age 30.

In 2020, he received a letter from Remus, the firm that manages the building, saying that it could cost thousands of pounds to fix the building’s fire safety issues. It was then that he realised the asset that was supposed to help to fund his retirement had suddenly become a huge drain on his finances.

Five years later and the cladding work has cost Law and his wife, Jennifer, £37,000, plus the costs associated with three failed sales. In February 2024, Law handed over the keys to his bank in a voluntary repossession, having seen his debts reach £82,000.

“By the end, we owed nearly £2,000 to the bank every month. Any equity we had in the property was just dwindling away,” said Law, 55, who lives in Wrexham.

In 2017 the fire at Grenfell Tower in west London killed 72 people and exposed widespread fire safety issues at buildings across the country.

More than 5,000 buildings have been identified as having unsafe cladding that needs to be removed. This has left many owners unable to sell their properties, while facing escalating service charges to fund repairs.

Law playing for Wolves in 1995

ALAMY

One of the main hurdles homeowners face is getting an EWS1 (external wall system) form, which outlines what needs to be done to improve safety or verifies that the building is safe. Many banks will not agree on a mortgage without one of these.

Martin Boyd from the campaign group Leasehold Knowledge Partnership said: “Eight years on from Grenfell we’re still seeing far too many people facing huge amounts of stress and costs due to the building safety crisis.”

A high-rise fire killed Catherine. The cladding firm kept on selling

‘Bankruptcy seems the only way out’

Law, from Merthyr Tydfil in Wales, burst on to the football scene in the 1980s as a teenage central defender at Queens Park Rangers and got his only cap for the national team in 1990. After suffering what he thought was a career-ending foot injury in 1992 he left the game for three years and went backpacking around the world.

It was on Baga beach in Goa during a kickabout with other travellers where he first thought he could return to the game. “I’ll be honest, I thought I might be able to play for Merthyr Tydfil,” he said.

He restarted his career at Wolves in 1994, but a snapped cruciate at his next club, Millwall, ended his playing days for good in 2000. Five years after that he bought the £380,000, three-bedroom penthouse in Birmingham with a £66,000 deposit. He chose an interest-only mortgage, hoping that the property would increase in value enough to clear the debt.

Law in Goa during the early 1990s

He and Jennifer lived in the flat for two years before renting it out, using the income to supplement his earnings from sports coaching and working with at-risk youths. They considered selling the property in 2010, when the family relocated to Australia for four years, now with two children in tow, but decided against it: “I thought, I’ll hold on to it and when HS2 is built and I’m 55, we’ll sell up and we’ll be OK in retirement,” Law said. “Then the cladding crisis happened and everything went wrong.”

Before his voluntary repossession, he owed £48,000 in mortgage payments, £10,000 in council tax and £24,000 in service charges.

Law is now in discussions with the Professional Footballers Association (PFA) about declaring himself bankrupt. “We have nothing: no savings, no pension, no income. We just want to move on and bankruptcy seems the only way out,” he said.

Health problems in recent years have made it even harder for the family to make money. Law suffers from an arthritic hip and requires ankle fusion surgery — both hangovers from his football career — and in 2022 was diagnosed with colon cancer, from which he received the all-clear in 2024.

The cladding scandal still retains its power to shock

“There are debt companies chasing me for council tax and service charges. I’ve spoken to the PFA and they said that bankruptcy is a way of starting afresh and getting on with my life,” he said.

Bankruptcy is a way of getting your debt written off, but can result in assets being taken from you and will significantly damage your credit score and ability to borrow cash, as well as barring you from certain jobs and positions in public office. In many cases, you will have to wait at least six years to secure a standard mortgage again. To declare bankruptcy, you must submit a petition to the courts and pay £680.

Law, who lives in a rented house in Wrexham, is aware of the financial implications but sees no other way out. He said: “I could spend the rest of my life paying back these debts, but they aren’t my fault and the only way to avoid having to pay back these unfair costs is to just draw a line under it.”

Giles Grover from the campaign group End Our Cladding Scandal said: “Sadly, Brian’s desperate situation is far from unique.

“Lives are still being ruined by the building safety scandal — whether the hundreds of thousands of people still trapped in their homes or landlords who, through no fault of their own, are seeing property prices dramatically affected.”

A spokesperson for Remus said: “Our duties to our client, the resident’s management company, preclude us from commenting on this particular case. However I can confirm that the remediation of the cladding on block C was completed on August 4, 2023.”

Was this article displayed correctly? Not happy with what you see?

Tabs Reminder: Tabs piling up in your browser? Set a reminder for them, close them and get notified at the right time.

Try our Chrome extension today!


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device