Jim Goodwin apologetic to Dundee United fans after Celtic loss


AI Summary Hide AI Generated Summary

Dundee United's Heavy Defeat

Dundee United suffered a 5-0 defeat against Celtic, prompting an apology from manager Jim Goodwin to the disappointed fans. Despite an initial aggressive game plan, which saw the team compete well for the opening 30 minutes, United's ambitious high-line strategy ultimately proved unsuccessful against Celtic's superior skill.

Goodwin's Analysis

Goodwin acknowledged the team's strong start, highlighting their aggressive press and ability to force turnovers. However, he admitted that Celtic's quality ultimately overwhelmed United, leading to a collapse after an own goal. He expressed embarrassment over the final scoreline, contrasting the initial 30 minutes with the subsequent defeat.

Game Events

  • Four changes were made to the starting lineup from the previous game.
  • A minute's silence was observed for Pope Francis.
  • A delay occurred due to a protest by Celtic supporters, throwing tangerines onto the pitch, in response to ticket prices.
  • Celtic scored five goals, with Kuhn and Idah each scoring twice.

Despite the heavy loss, Goodwin emphasized the importance of maintaining morale and focusing on the upcoming games. He stressed the team's need for continued fan support in the final stretch of the season.

Sign in to unlock more AI features Sign in with Google
We located an Open Access version of this article, legally shared by the author or publisher. Open It

Jim Goodwin has apologised to the Dundee United supporters after the Tangerines crashed to a 5-0 defeat against Celtic.

The United boss sought to implement a more aggressive outlook against the Hoops at Tannadice, with a pacy centre-back pairing of Vicko Sevelj and Emmanuel Adegboyega designed to allow the hosts to play a high line.

That was complimented by a combative midfield trio of Ross Docherty, Craig Sibbald and Allan Campbell.

But despite a bright start, the Terrors fell apart following Ryan Strain’s own goal, and Celtic mercilessly exploited the gaps in United’s ambitious set-up, which was night and day compared to the stoic defensive effort that got a 0-0 draw in December.

Nicolas Kuhn and Adam Idah went on to grab doubles as the Hoops ran riot and rubber-stamped their 13th Scottish Premiership title in the last 14, with Goodwin acknowledging that the afternoon became “embarrassing”.

Embarrassed

“For the opening half an hour, I thought we were very good,” said Goodwin. “The shape of the team was good, and we were aggressive with the press. We forced Celtic into playing a lot longer than they would normally like.

Jim Goodwin sees his side torn apart. Image: SNS

“It was a different approach to what we have done in the past. You’re kind of damned if you do, damned if you don’t. You can sit off the game and sit in a low block for 90 minutes; try and contain them and hope to hit them on the break.

“Or you can do what we tried to do, which was to go and get after them at the top end of the pitch and force turnovers. I thought in that opening 30 minutes, we did that numerous times and got lots of crosses into the box.

“But Celtic – with the quality that they have – can soon figure you out and they find a way to break you down. I don’t think it’ll be a great surprise to most people that Celtic have won here.

“However, we’re a bit embarrassed ourselves with the way the scoreline looks.”

The game is delayed

Goodwin made four changes to the side the defeated St Johnstone last time out. Luca Stephenson, whose season is over following surgery on a double hernia, Declan Gallagher, Sam Cleall-Harding and Kristijan Trapanovski all dropped out.

They were replaced by Sevelj, Campbell, Sibbald – making his 100th appearance for the club – and Ruari Paton, with the Tangerines switching to a 4-4-1-1 shape.

Aside from a scattering of initial jeers which were quickly shouted down, a minute’s silence for the late Pope Francis was respectfully observed inside Tannadice. 

With pace in the backline and energy in the engine room, United’s game-plan, as outlined by Goodwin, was to aggressively harass their title-chasing visitors.

That led to the first two opportunities falling to the Terrors, with Ross Docherty heading a fine Ryan Strain delivery over the bar, before Paton warmed the palms of Viljamo Sinisalo.

The tangerines are removed by a staff member for the Tangerines. Image: SNS

With Goodwin’s charges competing well, there was an untimely delay in proceedings when the away supporters housed in the Carling Stand lobbed scores of tangerines onto the field of play to protest United’s decision to charge £42 for the fixture.

Several minutes passed as players and officials helped with the clean up operation.

“At that moment, I felt that we were really competitive,” reflected Goodwin. “We certainly didn’t want the break in play. It was a bit of a strange situation, and not one that I’ve experienced before.”

United’s collapse

United’s bright start was rendered meaningless when the Hoops claimed the lead on the half-hour mark.

Liam Scales outjumped Sam Dalby too easily to flick an Arne Engels corner to the back-post and, as he battled Jota, Strain inadvertently sent the ball into his own net.

Players pick up the tangerines based protest, after which Celtic claimed the lead. Image: SNS

And following the most proactive opening half-hour United had produced against Celtic all season, they collapsed following the opener.

Paton fired another tame shot into the arms of Sinisalo as the hosts sought parity and, within a minute, the Hoops’ lead was doubled.

A swift counterattack saw Daizen Maeda sent scampering down the left flank before producing a sensational delivery across the face of goal for Kuhn to slam into the roof of the net.

It was 3-0 before the break when another Maeda cut-back allowed Kuhn to fire his second of the game past Jack Walton, benefitting from an intelligent step-over from Idah.

Failing to keep the score down

United’s priority for the second period was to keep the score down as they sought to maintain their goal difference advantage over St Mirren in sixth spot.

However, they were further behind within three minutes of the restart when Alastair Johnston clipped a superb cross into the box, where Idah was waiting to power home a clinical header.

Idah heads beyond Jack Walton. Image: SNS

Celtic made it a five-star showing before the hour, with Callum McGegor allowed to run 30 yards unchecked – cutting through a powderpuff United midfield barrier – before teeing up Idah to beat Walton at his near post, joining Kuhn on a brace.

With Hibs up next at Easter Road, Goodwin added: “I am apologetic to the supporters for the way that the game just petered out. They’ve been really significant all season in the support that they’ve given the team.

“We’re going to need them over the next four games.

“We’ll not allow this one to affect the psychology of the group. There is still a hell of a lot to play for.”

đź§  Pro Tip

Skip the extension — just come straight here.

We’ve built a fast, permanent tool you can bookmark and use anytime.

Go To Paywall Unblock Tool
Sign up for a free account and get the following:
  • Save articles and sync them across your devices
  • Get a digest of the latest premium articles in your inbox twice a week, personalized to you (Coming soon).
  • Get access to our AI features

  • Save articles to reading lists
    and access them on any device
    If you found this app useful,
    Please consider supporting us.
    Thank you!

    Save articles to reading lists
    and access them on any device
    If you found this app useful,
    Please consider supporting us.
    Thank you!