New clues point to engine failure for cause of Air India plane crash


AI Summary Hide AI Generated Summary

Key Findings

The most probable cause of the Air India Boeing 787 crash in Ahmedabad, India, resulting in at least 279 fatalities, is believed to be a loss of engine power. Videos and reports suggest the aircraft experienced significantly reduced thrust from both General Electric GEnx engines during takeoff, failing to gain sufficient altitude before crashing.

Evidence of Engine Failure

  • Videos show the plane struggling to climb, using the entire runway. Dust was thrown up after the end of the runway suggesting the plane was not airborne.
  • The co-pilot's Mayday call indicated 'Thrust not achieved'.
  • Deployment of the Ram Air Turbine (RAT), automatically activated in case of electrical and hydraulic power loss, was confirmed by videos and the distinctive propeller sound captured.
  • The sole surviving passenger reported flickering lights and a loud bang, potentially linked to an engine flameout or RAT deployment.
  • The extended undercarriage after takeoff further supports the dual engine failure theory.

Expert Opinions

Aviation experts, including experienced Boeing pilots, concur that the evidence strongly suggests a dual engine failure. The RAT, while providing minimal emergency control, is not designed to allow for climbing after takeoff.

Ongoing Investigation

The investigation continues, analyzing flight recorders and wreckage to determine the precise cause of the apparent power failure. Possible causes under consideration include fuel contamination and engine electronic control system malfunction. A bird strike has been ruled out.

Sign in to unlock more AI features Sign in with Google

A loss of engine power is emerging as the most likely cause of the crash of the Air India Boeing that killed at least 279 people at Ahmedabad on Thursday.

The Boeing 787-8 series appeared to have suffered from lower than normal thrust from its General Electric GEnx engines as it took off and failed to climb more than 450ft before crashing, video and reports from the Indian authorities have indicated.

The new information has eclipsed an early focus on the unusual configuration of the aircraft’s wing flaps and landing gear.

No cause has yet been identified for what would be an extremely rare power loss from both engines, but on Sunday the Indian civil air authority (DGCA) began urgent pre-flight inspections of fuel systems, electronic engine controls and other systems on Indian Boeing 787s.

Juan Browne, an American airlines Boeing pilot who runs a well-regarded aviation YouTube channel, said: “There was something terribly wrong with this 787 jet and we need to find out really quickly what went wrong because we’ve got a thousand of these operating today and operators need to find out what happened.” The Indian authorities confirmed on Sunday that the 787, the high-tech flagship of the Boeing fleet, struggled to become airborne, using almost all of the 3,500m runway. That is notably more than the length that would have been calculated by the plane’s computer for the hot conditions and heavy load that day. Video of the take-off showed dust thrown up after the end of the runway, indicating power from both engines as the plane passed over. In his emergency call seconds after take-off, the co-pilot told air traffic controllers: “Thrust not achieved … falling … Mayday! Mayday! Mayday!”, according to local aviation sources. Further evidence of a power problem came from another video of the brief flight. This confirmed that the aircraft’s “ram air turbine” (RAT) had been deployed.The RAT, consisting of two propeller-like blades, drops on an arm from under the rear of the fuselage to generate enough electricity to power essential electric and hydraulic systems. This occurs automatically if the aircraft loses electrical and hydraulic power, which normally comes from three independent systems. Videos captured the plane struggling to climb before crashingJAM PRESS/RARE SHOT NEWSThe distinctive “burring” noise, similar to a propeller plane, from the high-speed blades driven by the oncoming air, is clear in the video.Testimony from Vishwash Kumar Ramesh, the sole surviving passenger, also indicated an electrical power failure. The cabin lights flickered and he heard a bang, he said. The noise could have come from an engine “flame-out” or from the RAT deploying, pilots said. Ramesh also said the engines appeared to be revving up when the plane hit the ground, suggesting that some power was still available.Steve Scheibner, an American Airlines Boeing 777 captain, said the new evidence showed the Indian Boeing had suffered a double power loss rather than a loss of lift caused by other factors, as first suspected.“I’m solidly in the camp that there was dual engine failure. The RAT is deployed. you can hear it,” he said. The turbine is not intended to provide enough power and controls for an aircraft to climb after take-off, merely to give minimum control for an emergency descent from altitude, he added.A power loss would explain why the Boeing’s undercarriage remained extended after take-off because the emergency turbine is not designed to provide power to retract it. The cause of the apparent power failure will emerge from analysis of the flight recorders and study of the wreckage. This could range from fuel contamination to failure in the engines’ electronic control systems. The Indian authorities indicated that a bird strike has been ruled out. “We have no idea why both engines on a 787 would flame out right after take off,” Scheibner said.

Was this article displayed correctly? Not happy with what you see?

Tabs Reminder: Tabs piling up in your browser? Set a reminder for them, close them and get notified at the right time.

Try our Chrome extension today!


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device