Dear Prudence is Slateâs advice column. Submit questions here.
Dear Prudence,
ââRecently, I had a fight so big with my boyfriend at Walmart that I just ran out to the car and drove home, leaving him at the store. Hereâs where he messed up.
I was wearing running shorts that went down to just above the knee. This older woman comes up behind me and loudly says, âsheâs showing her ass to the whole store!â I turned around and said, âexcuse me?â She told me I was dressed âway too sluttyâ to be out in public. I turned to my boyfriend for support, and he averted his eyes. âAre you gonna let her talk to me that way?â I asked. âForget it, letâs just go,â he replied, in an irritated voice.
I folded my arms and said, âNo. This lady called me a name and I want you to defend me.â âSorry about my girlfriend, maâam. Would you mind just walking away?â my boyfriend said to the lady. I couldnât believe my boyfriend had taken her side over mine. I wanted to scream at him in frustration, but we were in public so I just left him there. He had to call an Uber to get home. Prudie, I canât be with someone who doesnât have my back. Iâm ready to throw him out over this. He says Iâm making too big a deal and to let it go. Who is right?
âFurious at Flaky Boyfriend
Dear Furious,
I donât like that your boyfriend apologized to this totally out-of-line prude for you. But itâs tough to ask him to have your back more than you had your own back. Itâs not as if you were approached by a big scary guy in a dark alley. You were more than capable of verbally defending yourself against a senior citizen by saying something more powerful than âExcuse me?â
But we donât have to unpack the entire interaction to conclude that you two should break up. The key phrases in your letter are âI canât be with someone whoâ and âIâm ready to throw him out.â You donât have to get an outside ruling to break up with him just because you want to, especially if being disappointed by the way he reacts to situations is a pattern. There is no ârightâ and no âtoo big a dealâ in love. You simply get to look for a person who makes you happy. If that, for you, means a person who would have said, âIf you say one more word to my girlfriend about her completely appropriate running shorts Iâm going to film it, put it on TikTok, and let the commenters destroy you,â then that is your right. You can move on. Which is good because, honestly, abandoning someone at Walmart is a tough thing to come back from.
Please keep questions short (<150 words), and donât submit the same question to multiple columns. We are unable to edit or remove questions after publication. Use pseudonyms to maintain anonymity. Your submission may be used in other Slate advice columns and may be edited for publication.
Thanks! Your question has been submitted.
Dear Prudence,
Iâm under five feet tall and get rather claustrophobic when pushed to the back of a crowded elevator. What can I do to make people more considerate?
âNot So Little World
Dear Little World,
I donât think itâs common knowledge that being short would make a person feel uncomfortable in the back of a crowded elevator, so even the most considerate person might not think to move out of the way. Itâs not a concert! That said, now that you mention it, I can absolutely see how being smashed between a wall and someoneâs middle back would feel awful.
You can do one of two things:
1)Â Prepare a line that you always deploy in this situation, like, âExcuse me! Do you mind if I squeeze in front of you? Short person problems!â
2)Â Each time the door opens, get off with the people exiting on that floor and then get right back on in a non-claustrophobia-inducing position by the doors.
Dear Prudence,
For the parental guilt trip files: My mom is slow, and tired, and crabby. A normal amount for 80ish. My brother and I are middle aged, and hitting a phase in life where the kids are launched, or nearly, and thereâs time and money to spare. Weâve started traveling together, with our spouses. I like his wife, he likes my husband, we all share interests, and we make a good traveling foursome.
Each time weâve taken a trip together, my mom has posted pictures we sent her on her own Facebook, with a comment about how jealous she is that her kids are doing cool stuff and how she wasnât invited. We resolved to stop sending her pictures, but if she knows weâre traveling, she begs for them. So we complied, with requests not to post publicly. She âforgotâ and did it anyway. So we didnât tell her about the next trip, and then she took pictures from our social media after the fact and did the same damn thing. âMy kids went to the Grand Canyon! How I would have loved to see it again before I dieâŚâ Or, âI asked if there was room for me on the kidsâ trip to London, but it âdidnât work out this timeâ and then all her elderly friends commented about how they too are âleft behindâ by the younger generation.
Her hurt seems enough that Iâve started to question the situation! On the one hand, this is the perfect time for us to do this; our knees wonât hold out forever for the kind of active travel we currently enjoy. And traveling with mom is a non-starter, since she needs multiple naps a day and takes a half-hour to traverse a city block. We do visit them a couple times a year, and on the rare occasion they visit us in our cities, we make every accommodation (paying for parking downtown or taking cabs, instead of herding everyone on the subway, for example) and slow our lives waaaaay down to make it nice for them. I thought we were doing OK in terms of including them and still living our own lives. But sheâs making me wonder if our sibling trips are objectively exclusionary and hurtful?
âAll My Trips Are Guilt Trips Now
Dear Guilt Trips,
I think itâs possible that your mom is just saying stuff. By that I mean, there may be not be any sadness or jealousy behind her posts. Think of how, when someone says theyâre going to Hawaii, a coworker might reply, âCan you put me in your suitcase?â Or an acquaintance might comment âso jealous!â on the social media post of someone who shared a video from the front row of a BeyoncĂŠ concert. âThat looks like an amazing experienceâ can take a form that sounds a lot like âI wish Iâd been included.â But this isnât always literal, similar to how, when you share a photo of yourself on the beach and say âTake me back,â it doesnât mean youâre actively looking for someone to buy you a plane ticket; it just means you wanted everyone to be reminded of that time you looked really good in a swimsuit and needed something to put in the caption.
My Mother-in-Law Keeps Telling Us Weâre Failing Our Daughter in a Major Way. Enough! This Content is Available for Slate Plus members only Help! I Just Abandoned My Boyfriend at Walmart Over the Ultimate Betrayal. My Boyfriend Has an Upsetting Secret. Itâs Bad Enough to Leave Him, but ⌠Iâm Intrigued. This Content is Available for Slate Plus members only I Did a Nice Gesture for My Sister-in-Law. I Had No Idea It Would Set Off My Family Like This.I would go as far as to guess that your mom may be really proud of your travels or appreciate the conversation fodder the images provide. For many older people whose worlds have become a bit smaller due to their declining health and mobility, adult kid updates are an important social currency. Your vacation photos may really be big news for her, and the engagement they inspire (even if it comes in the form of grouchy comments) could be welcomed interaction.
But if you think your mom is really communicating that she would like to be on these trips and is truly sad about being excluded, talk to her! âI saw your post about London and how you wished you were included and I felt a little bad. With all the walking and the busy itinerary we planned, we didnât think it would be something you were physically up to.â And then, if itâs really just her knees and need for naps (rather than money, or a difficult personality) standing in the way of including her, make an offer: âWould you want to come on our next trip and relax at the hotel while she did all our running around?â Or âWe could talk about planning a cabin getaway or something more mellow for sometime this year, if youâd be interested.â Assuming sheâs not in denial about her physical abilities, she should be able to tell you what she really wants to do.
Catch up on this weekâs Prudie.
More Advice From Slate
Iâm traveling for college at the end of the summer, and Iâm still a virgin. I had many boyfriends during the past years but never had sex with any of themânot because I wasnât ready, but because it just didnât happen. Last summer I met someone, and we went on several dates but at the end had an on-and-off friends-with-benefits relationship. Right now I feel ready to have sex with him, but since itâs my first time and since heâs not my boyfriend, Iâm scared Iâm going to regret it when I get olderâŚ
Skip the extension â just come straight here.
Weâve built a fast, permanent tool you can bookmark and use anytime.
Go To Paywall Unblock Tool