Stonehenge was built by black Britons, children’s history book claims


AI Summary Hide AI Generated Summary

Controversial Claims

A children's book, "Brilliant Black British History," asserts that Stonehenge was constructed during a period when Britain was predominantly a black country. This claim is based on the argument that the earliest Britons were black, citing Cheddar Man's dark skin. The book also discusses the diverse ethnicities present in Britain throughout history, highlighting the contributions of black individuals and communities.

Historical Debate

Historians have raised concerns, arguing that the book presents misinformation. They point to recent genetic analyses suggesting that the Stonehenge builders were pale-skinned early farmers from Anatolia. They also criticize the book's generalizations about skin color and its linking of specific achievements to particular races. The book's approach has been characterized by some as "wokeness" and "brainwashing." Others have compared it to similar racially motivated historical revisionisms.

Key Arguments

  • The book claims Britain was a black country for thousands of years before the arrival of white people.
  • Historians dispute this, citing genetic evidence suggesting a different origin for the builders of Stonehenge.
  • The book highlights the contributions of black people throughout British history.
  • The book's methodology has been described as flawed and potentially misleading to young readers.

Further Points

The book also details the presence of black people in Britain across various periods, including Roman times, the Middle Ages, and the post-World War II era. It mentions the Windrush generation and the significance of the Black Lives Matter movement. However, the accuracy of some of its claims and its overall approach have been called into question.

Sign in to unlock more AI features Sign in with Google

Stonehenge was built by black Britons, a new children’s history book has claimed.

The illustrated book entitled Brilliant Black British History, by the Nigerian-born British author Atinuke, says “every single British person comes from a migrant” but “the very first Britons were black”.

Readers of the newly released book are told that Stonehenge was built while Britain was “a black country”.

The book, published by Bloomsbury and promoted by Arts Council-funded literacy charity The Book Trust, states that: “Britain was a black country for more than 7,000 years before white people came, and during that time the most famous British monument was built, Stonehenge.”

The introduction says that “Britain has been a mostly white country for a lot less time than it has been a mostly black country”.

Atinuke’s book, for readers aged seven-plus, takes the reader through a chronological overview of black people’s presence in Britain, saying that Cheddar Man, the oldest human remains found in Britain, had skin “as dark as dark can be”.

‘A hodgepodge of people’

The claims made in the book have caused concern among some historians that children could be brought up reading “misinformation”.

The leaders of 2018 research into Cheddar Man’s DNA said it was impossible to know with certainty how this early inhabitant looked, and other researchers noted problems with attempting to predict skin tone from the genetic model used.

Recent genetic analysis has shown that the inhabitants of Britain in the period when Stonehenge was completed, around 2,500 BC, were pale-skinned early farmers whose ancestors had spread from Anatolia.

On a page featuring an image of a black Roman legionary fighting a white Celt, Atinuke’s book says Rome “turned back to Europe and pushed north” to conquer Britain after first being unable to take the African kingdom of Nubia.

The book states that the Roman historian Tacitus reported that the Silures people in Wales were “dark-skinned and curly-haired”. In Tacitus’ full account, he theorised that they may have been from Spain.

It adds that by the Middle Ages, Britain was “a hodgepodge of people: original British migrants, Celts, Romans, Britons, Anglo-Saxons, Vikings, Africans and Normans”, adding: “They spoke a hodgepodge language too – English”.

In the period of the Tudors and Stewarts, an incoming black Muslim population brought “new knowledge about textiles, medicine, maths and navigation”.

Windrush generation

The book says that following the Second World War, “Britain needed help” and so the “government asked people from the colonies to come”. These included the Windrush generation and others from countries that had been “left poor after slavery and colonisation”.

It also includes a page on Black Lives Matter, which states that although “race does not scientifically exist”, black people suffer “institutional racism”.

Atinuke’s book has caused concern among historians, with Dr Zareer Masani saying it “seems typical of the kind of wokedom that’s been colonising our schools and universities”.

He claimed it was “evidence of brainwashing children with outright lies, confusion and misinformation”.

David Abulafia, a historian and Cambridge emeritus professor, said: “The Nazis claimed that the cultural achievements of the north were the work of blond, fair-skinned folk.

“Making skin colour a criterion for judging great achievements like Stonehenge is therefore not a new idea. It is also rubbish. It only gets interesting if their skins were blue or green.”

Representatives of Atinuke have been approached for comment.

Was this article displayed correctly? Not happy with what you see?

Tabs Reminder: Tabs piling up in your browser? Set a reminder for them, close them and get notified at the right time.

Try our Chrome extension today!


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device