UK Government panned over 'dangerous' migrant crime league table plans | The National


AI Summary Hide AI Generated Summary

Controversy over Migrant Crime Data

The UK government's plan to release data on the nationalities and crimes of migrants awaiting deportation has sparked significant controversy. The Scottish Refugee Council and Scottish Greens voiced concerns about the potential dangers of such publication, warning it could incite anti-migrant sentiment and cause harm. They highlight the risk of generalizing the behavior of a few to entire communities.

Opposition and Concerns

Critics, including the Scottish Refugee Council's chief executive Sabir Zazai, argue the initiative is counterproductive and could endanger migrants. They point to previous instances of divisive rhetoric leading to violence and cite fears of further attacks against vulnerable individuals. The Scottish Greens MSP Maggie Chapman emphasizes that this move is not in the interest of public safety but instead will create harmful generalizations.

Government Response

A Home Office source countered by stating that the government is deporting foreign criminals at an unprecedented rate and will publish more information than previous administrations. However, the source did not clarify whether the statistics would include data from Scotland.

Uncertainties

The article notes uncertainty about data sharing between Scotland and the UK government, highlighting a lack of transparency regarding the data's scope and methodology. The article concludes by highlighting the opposition and concerns voiced by various stakeholders about the potential negative impact of the government's actions.

Sign in to unlock more AI features Sign in with Google
We located an Open Access version of this article, legally shared by the author or publisher. Open It

The Scottish Refugee Council has warned that there are “obvious dangers” in publishing the data.

The Scottish Greens, meanwhile, said that Labour are “fanning the flames of the anti-migrant agenda”. 

It comes after Home Secretary Yvette Cooper is understood to have ordered officials to publish data by the end of the year showing the nationalities and crimes of those awaiting deportation.

READ MORE: Nicola Sturgeon and Jeremy Corbyn to appear at 'world's largest philosophy festival'

A Home Office source told The Telegraph: “Not only are we deporting foreign criminals at a rate never seen when Chris Philp and Robert Jenrick were in charge at the Home Office, but we will also be publishing far more information about that cohort of offenders than the Tories ever did.”

It is unclear as to whether these statistics will include data from Scotland given it may involve some data sharing.

 The National has approached the Scottish and UK Government for clarification. 

But now, Scottish Refugee Council chief executive Sabir Zazai has hit out at the move. 

“We do not understand what the UK Government hopes to achieve by publishing this data in this way, but there are obvious dangers in doing so,” he said.

“It has been less than a year since divisive and dehumanising rhetoric escalated to violence and rioting on UK streets. Many of the people we support – people who had already been forced to flee war, conflict and persecution – were too scared to go outside because they were afraid of what might happen to them. We all have a role to play in ensuring that never happens again.

Zazai added: “The criminal justice system is responsible for prosecuting individuals who have broken the law. No respectable government should be seeking to use the actions of a select few to unduly influence people’s views of entire communities.”

Scottish Greens MSP Maggie Chapman (below), meanwhile, said publication of the table is “not being done as a matter of public safety or interest”.

(Image: Christian Gamauf)

“But it will create a harmful sweeping generalisation, claiming that all migrants are dangerous, when that simply is not true,” she added. 

“The vast majority of migrants who come to the UK do so in good faith, to live and work, to build their lives here, to study, to pay taxes and give back to the communities that they now call home.

“We know that police forces across the UK have highlighted the problems they face with institutional racism, which will result in a disproportionate amount of reports on people of colour and migrants over the reports on crimes committed by white British nationals.

“The UK Government must think again before they make these claims in the name of public safety, and consider the harm that could be caused to innocent people and their families who fit the nationalities or criminal stereotyping that Labour are trying to push.”

đź§  Pro Tip

Skip the extension — just come straight here.

We’ve built a fast, permanent tool you can bookmark and use anytime.

Go To Paywall Unblock Tool
Sign up for a free account and get the following:
  • Save articles and sync them across your devices
  • Get a digest of the latest premium articles in your inbox twice a week, personalized to you (Coming soon).
  • Get access to our AI features

  • Save articles to reading lists
    and access them on any device
    If you found this app useful,
    Please consider supporting us.
    Thank you!

    Save articles to reading lists
    and access them on any device
    If you found this app useful,
    Please consider supporting us.
    Thank you!