Who is ahead in the global tech race?


AI Summary Hide AI Generated Summary

Global Tech Race: A Multifaceted Competition

A Harvard study ranks 25 countries across five tech sectors: AI, semiconductors, biotechnology, space, and quantum technology. The United States leads overall, but other nations are rapidly closing the gap.

Artificial Intelligence: A Close Contest

While the US holds a significant lead in AI due to early breakthroughs and dominant companies like OpenAI and Nvidia, China is a strong competitor. China's cost-effective AI models, relaxed data privacy rules, and substantial talent pool in computer science and engineering pose a significant challenge. China's researchers published a higher percentage of AI papers than the US and Europe in 2023. India, despite its potential, lags due to underinvestment and insufficient training data.

Semiconductors: Manufacturing Matters

The US maintains an advantage in chip design, but East Asian countries—China, Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea—excel in manufacturing capacity and access to specialized materials. China's high ranking stems from its massive lower-end chip production, though it lacks advanced-node facilities. The index also underscores the importance of critical chokepoints in the global supply chain like ASML (Netherlands) and TSMC (Taiwan).

Biotechnology and Other Sectors

The US leads in biotechnology, primarily due to its strengths in vaccine research and genetic engineering. However, China's lead in drug production and larger biotech scientific workforce suggests a potential future shift in dominance. Europe underperforms commercially despite strong academic contributions. Russia shows relative strength only in the space sector, a legacy of its Soviet past.

Challenges and Future Outlook

The US's technological leadership is threatened by policies that deter foreign talent and cut research funding. Conversely, China's coordinated and practical AI development highlights the shift towards prioritizing implementation over theoretical breakthroughs. The future balance of global power may depend not only on innovation, but also on the efficient deployment of technology.

Sign in to unlock more AI features Sign in with Google

TECHNOLOGICAL STRENGTH brings economic growth, geopolitical influence and military might. But tracking who leads in a given field, and by how much, is tricky. An index by researchers at Harvard, published on June 5th, attempts to measure such heft. It ranks 25 countries across five sectors: artificial intelligence (AI), semiconductors, biotechnology, space and quantum technology. America dominates the rankings, but other countries are closing in.

Of all the sectors, AI gets the most attention from politicians. J.D. Vance, America’s vice-president, recently called its development an “arms race". America commands a strong lead thanks to its early breakthroughs, its head start in building computing power and the dominance of firms such as OpenAI and Nvidia. But China’s DeepSeek R1 rivals Western models at a fraction of the cost. China’s loose attitudes towards data privacy, and its deep pools of talent in computer science and engineering, give it an edge. In 2023 Chinese researchers produced around 23% of all published papers on AI—more than Americans (9%) and Europeans (15%).

India, long tipped to be a world tech power, ranks tenth overall, and seventh for its development of AI. It has plenty of engineering talent and hundreds of millions of internet users. But weak investment and a scarcity of training data needed for large language models has slowed its progress. So far, India has yet to produce a major AI breakthrough.

View Full Image

Chart: The Economist

The AI race runs on semiconductors, which carry the most weight in the index. America’s lead here is narrower: it is ahead in chip design but East Asia remains the industrial centre of gravity. China, Japan, Taiwan and South Korea each beat America in manufacturing capacity and access to specialised materials (see chart 1).

But a country can score highly on manufacturing without producing cutting-edge chips. China, for example, has no advanced-node facilities (factories capable of making the most complex chips) yet it ranks well thanks to the sheer scale of its lower-end chipmaking. The index also misses critical chokepoints in the global supply chain. ASML, based in the Netherlands (ranked 15th), is the sole maker of the world’s most advanced chipmaking machines. Taiwan (8th) is home to TSMC, which churns out up to 90% of the most powerful transistors.

View Full Image

Chart: The Economist

In other fields the top spot is more closely contested (see chart 2). America still leads in biotechnology because of its strengths in vaccine research and genetic engineering. But China is ahead in drug production, and has a larger cohort of biotech scientists. Over the past decade China has dramatically increased its biotechnology research capabilities. If this trend continues, China could soon pull ahead. Europe again underwhelms: its academic strengths have not translated into commercial success. Russia’s highest score comes in the space sector, a legacy of the Soviet era, but it falls short everywhere else.

America’s lead in critical technologies once felt unassailable. But the Trump administration risks undermining that position: by deterring top foreign talent and cutting research funding it will sap the flow of ideas that have sustained America’s position at the top. (The Harvard researchers behind the index will be no strangers to Donald Trump’s attack on universities.)

China’s rise, meanwhile, has been swift and co-ordinated. Its AI push focuses on practical use over theoretical breakthroughs. The next phase of global power may be decided not just by who invents the most powerful tools, but by who puts them to work first.

Was this article displayed correctly? Not happy with what you see?

Tabs Reminder: Tabs piling up in your browser? Set a reminder for them, close them and get notified at the right time.

Try our Chrome extension today!


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device


Share this article with your
friends and colleagues.
Earn points from views and
referrals who sign up.
Learn more

Facebook

Save articles to reading lists
and access them on any device