Alastair Campbellโ€™s diary: Whoโ€™s really to blame for populism? - The New European

See original article

Analysis of Populism

The article discusses the rise of populism, particularly focusing on the roles of politicians and the media. It questions the assessment that blames the public for the success of populist movements, arguing that the political establishment also bears significant responsibility.

Critique of Peter Hyman's Argument

Alastair Campbell agrees with much of Peter Hyman's analysis of the populist surge but disagrees with Hyman's placing of primary blame on 'people like us'. Campbell argues that politicians and their intellectual backers played a crucial role in creating and exploiting the conditions that led to the rise of populism. He highlights the need for a balanced approach, acknowledging shortcomings while also holding politicians accountable.

The Role of Media and Political Discourse

The article touches upon the importance of written communication in contrast to the spoken word, especially in the realm of political analysis and discourse. Campbell asserts the value of well-considered written speeches compared to interviews. He emphasizes the need for a balanced approach using both written and spoken communication.

Historical Perspective on Shifting Global Power Dynamics

A memo from a US military expert, Lin Wells, to Donald Rumsfeld, is presented. The memo highlights the unpredictable shifts in global power dynamics and the challenges of anticipating future scenarios. This underscores the complexity of political forecasting and planning. This is further emphasized by the inclusion of another memo from Rumsfeld to his under secretary of defense, outlining policy challenges.

Conclusion

The article concludes by highlighting the unpredictable nature of global politics and the need for adaptability in political strategy and policy-making. It underscores the importance of thoughtful analysis, effective communication (both written and spoken), and holding both politicians and their enablers accountable for the rise of populism.

Sign up for a free account and get the following:
  • Save articles and sync them across your devices
  • Get a digest of the latest premium articles in your inbox twice a week, personalized to you (Coming soon).
  • Get access to our AI features