Three renowned Yale professors—Timothy Snyder, Marci Shore, and Jason Stanley—have relocated to the University of Toronto, sparking debate about their decision. While their reasons are partly personal, they cite a growing authoritarianism within the US under the Trump administration as a major factor.
The author questions whether leaving during a challenging period constitutes a betrayal of American ideals. He contrasts the professors' decision with those who choose to stay and fight for democratic values. The departure is viewed by some as a preemptive concession to authoritarianism, a rejection of fighting for the country's democratic principles.
The author explores the concept of transactional citizenship, where individuals' commitment to a nation is contingent on its adherence to specific values. This perspective is exemplified by a British journalist who returned to London after Trump's election and a former government official who plans to expatriate due to America's perceived betrayal of its ideals.
The article emphasizes the ongoing struggle against the erosion of American democracy. The author argues that the fight is far from over and encourages readers to remain engaged and resist attempts to undermine democratic principles. Key to this struggle is maintaining belief in America's ideals and the continued fight to preserve them.
Ultimately, the article concludes with a call to remain committed and fight for the preservation of democracy, reflecting Timothy Snyder's 'Lesson 19: Be a patriot.'