‘Can’t be both’ heritage advocate and panel member | Otago Daily Times Online News

Concerns Raised

A housing advocacy group questioned the appointment of Dunedin City Councillor Sophie Barker to a hearings panel considering adding 146 properties to the city's heritage register. Aaron Hawkins, a former mayor and strategic lead for the Otago Housing Alliance, argued that Barker's previous advocacy for heritage buildings creates a conflict of interest, making it impossible for her to be an impartial decision-maker.

Panel's Response

Independent commissioner Rob van Voorthuysen, chair of the panel, stated he obtained independent legal counsel and spoke with Cr Barker. He confirmed he's satisfied there's no conflict of interest and that she'll approach her role with an open mind. He plans to remind all panel members of their responsibilities before the hearing begins.

Key Points

• Concerns revolve around potential bias due to Cr Barker's prior advocacy.
• The panel includes Cr Barker, Cr Jim O’Malley, and independent commissioner Rob van Voorthuysen.
• The hearing for plan change 1 begins on May 19.
• The Otago Housing Alliance expressed neutrality on the list of buildings proposed but stressed public health implications should be considered alongside heritage values.