Govt’s lateral entry scheme: Politics stalled it, now case awaits legal process | India News - The Indian Express

India's Stalled Lateral Entry Scheme

The Indian government's lateral entry scheme, aimed at bringing in talent from outside the bureaucracy through contractual appointments, has been significantly delayed due to legal and political challenges.

Legal Standoff

A 2020 court case, initiated by an Indian Forest Service officer, challenges the scheme's legal basis, arguing that it lacks procedural rigor and violates constitutional provisions regarding recruitment to government positions. The case has been transferred between various courts, with a final referral to a larger Supreme Court bench in March 2023, yet awaits a hearing.

Key Contentions

• Constitutional Questions: The applicant argues that the scheme bypasses the constitutional scheme of permanent civil services and the prescribed methods of recruitment.
• Conflict of Interest: Concerns are raised regarding potential conflicts of interest and inadequate verification methods for candidates from the private sector.
• Lack of Need: The applicant questions the necessity of lateral entry given the abundant number of applications from empaneled officers for the same positions.

The Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) counters these arguments, primarily citing the doctrine of pleasure and the need for specialized expertise.

Current Status

Despite being referred to a larger Supreme Court bench, the case remains pending, leaving the future of the lateral entry scheme uncertain after years of delays.