A Dunedin City councillor, Carmen Houlahan, is leading a motion to overturn a controversial decision to lease the upper floor of the South Dunedin library complex at commercial rates. This follows criticism from the community and community organizations about a perceived broken promise regarding affordable community space in the new facility.
Cr Houlahan, who initially voted for the commercial lease plan, now admits to making the wrong decision and feels the previous decision is a betrayal of the community’s input and expectations. The motion is backed by several other councillors and could be voted on at the end of the month.
The South Dunedin Community Network voiced concerns, citing that the decision felt like a betrayal after extensive community consultation for the building's design. Numerous community groups have contacted councillors to express their disappointment and request the council to fulfill its earlier promises.
However, Cr Bill Acklin disagrees, stating that there were no broken promises, and that leasing the upstairs space was always part of the plan when the council decided on the King Edward St site for the library. He contends that sufficient community space remains on the ground floor.
Grey Power Otago president, Jo Millar, highlights a misconception that the community wants free space. They are willing to pay but cannot afford market rates. She mentions the possibility of a petition and street march if a resolution is not reached.