‘Infinite License’ | Omer Bartov | The New York Review of Books

See original article

Comparing the Herero Genocide and the Gaza Conflict

The article establishes a parallel between the German genocide of the Herero people in 1904 and the Israeli actions in Gaza in 2023. Both instances involved the dehumanization of a targeted group, leading to their extermination or displacement.

Israel's Justification and the Holocaust

Israel's actions in Gaza are justified as a response to a potential genocide, drawing comparisons to the Holocaust. This framing, however, is criticized as a distortion of the Holocaust's historical context and lessons.

The Nature of a Jewish State

The article explores the concept of a Jewish state, contrasting it with a state for Jews. It argues that Israel's prioritization of Jewish identity over democratic principles has led to the erosion of democratic values and the oppression of Palestinians.

The Reality in Gaza

The author describes the widespread destruction and loss of life in Gaza, citing reports from various sources, including the UN and international NGOs. The systematic targeting of civilians and infrastructure points towards a genocidal intent.

Moral Abdication and Global Response

The article critiques the global community's response to the conflict, noting a moral abdication in the face of Israel's actions. The author questions how the world could allow a genocide to occur, especially in light of the Holocaust's lessons.

Consequences and Future

The author suggests the potential long-term consequences of Israel's actions, including a reevaluation of its unique status and the need for future generations to confront the legacy of genocide. The article concludes by highlighting the interconnected nature of the Holocaust and the Palestinian suffering.

Sign up for a free account and get the following:
  • Save articles and sync them across your devices
  • Get a digest of the latest premium articles in your inbox twice a week, personalized to you (Coming soon).
  • Get access to our AI features