This article analyzes the common ground between the Irish rap group Kneecap and politicians such as Boris Johnson, Giorgia Meloni, and Donald Trump. The author introduces the concept of "Notspeak," a form of communication characterized by self-cancelling statements and ironic detachment, allowing for deniability.
The author argues that "Notspeak" enables a type of politics that is superficially clownish but has severe consequences. It is described as a way of transgressing social and political norms under the guise of humor, making it difficult to hold those who employ it accountable.
The article examines Kneecap's lyrics and actions, highlighting their ambiguous statements, such as calls to violence against MPs and apparent support for Hamas and Hizbullah. It emphasizes the difficulty in differentiating between artistic expression and political incitement.
The author concludes that while artists have the right to political intervention, they should recognize that their claims on reality are not mere performance. The article emphasizes the potential harm of language that undermines meaning, particularly in the political sphere, where it can result in real-world violence and damage.