The article contends that Pierre Poilievre's leadership of the Conservative Party should be reconsidered. Key arguments include his significant lead in the election being squandered, his loss of his own seat, and his perceived lack of likeability and authenticity. His populist style, compared unfavorably to that of Donald Trump, is also cited as a factor in his party's loss. Furthermore, his divisive leadership style, alienating figures like Ontario Premier Doug Ford, is highlighted as a weakness.
Despite these criticisms, the author believes Poilievre's removal is improbable. His strong showing in the popular vote, along with his political savvy and lack of a prominent challenger within the party, are cited as reasons for his continued leadership. The article mentions the difficulty of ousting a party leader and the relative lack of courage within the party to challenge him.