PETER HITCHENS: Spare me the hand-wringing over Ukraine. The West has been carving up much weaker countries in grubby peace deals for YEARS | Daily Mail Online

See original article

Hypocrisy in International Relations

The article challenges the West's condemnation of Russia's actions in Ukraine, arguing it's hypocritical given the West's history of altering borders and governments through force or agreements. Hitchens highlights several key examples:

  • The Iraq War (2003): The US and UK invasion to change Iraq's government.
  • Yalta Agreement (1945): The handing over of Eastern Europe to Stalin, including Poland's territorial changes.
  • Yugoslav Wars (1990s): The breakup of Yugoslavia, NATO bombing, and the creation of Kosovo.
  • Turkey's seizure of Northern Cyprus (1974): The ongoing occupation of Northern Cyprus.
  • Camp David Accords (1978): Israel's return of the Sinai Peninsula to Egypt.
  • Good Friday Agreement (1998): The UK's perceived surrender to the IRA in Northern Ireland.

Hitchens contends that these events demonstrate a double standard, where actions deemed acceptable by Western powers are condemned when undertaken by others. He emphasizes the lack of consequences for the West despite its involvement in similar actions, contrasting this with the pressure on Ukraine to accept unfavorable peace deals.

The Double Standard

The core argument revolves around the inconsistency of applying international norms. While the West criticizes Russia's actions, its own history reveals a pattern of intervening in other countries' affairs, often resulting in border changes and regime shifts. Hitchens suggests that this hypocrisy undermines the West's moral authority on the issue.

Consequences and Implications

The article implies that a more nuanced understanding of history is needed before judging current events. It questions the legitimacy of the international order, suggesting that power politics and self-interest often outweigh principles of non-intervention and territorial integrity.

Sign up for a free account and get the following:
  • Save articles and sync them across your devices
  • Get a digest of the latest premium articles in your inbox twice a week, personalized to you (Coming soon).
  • Get access to our AI features