What Canadians Heardโ€”and Americans Didnโ€™t | The New Yorker

See original article

Canadian Election Results

The Canadian Liberal Party, led by Mark Carney, won a minority government in the recent federal election, securing approximately 44% of the popular vote. The Conservatives, led by Pierre Poilievre, obtained around 41%, resulting in a close but decisive outcome. Carney's victory is largely attributed to the perceived threat posed by Donald Trump's rhetoric towards Canada.

Trump's Influence

Poilievre's support for the Ottawa truckers' protest, reminiscent of Trump's style, alienated many Canadians. His campaign's reliance on social media attacks and half-truths was a key factor in his defeat. Conversely, Trump's threats toward Canada, dismissed by many Americans, were taken seriously by Canadians, strengthening support for Carney's leadership.

Regional Dynamics

The election results exhibited regional disparities. While Western provinces remained resistant to the Liberal Party, Quebec, a traditional Liberal stronghold, returned to its allegiance. The NDP, meanwhile, suffered significant losses, partly due to progressive voters shifting to the Liberals.

The Threat of Annexation

The article highlights Trump's implicit threats of annexing Canada, emphasizing the lack of respect for Canadian sovereignty in his rhetoric. The author counters arguments about unfair trade practices between Canada and the US, demonstrating the absurdity of such claims. The article stresses the inherent absurdity of Canada becoming the '51st state' due to its diverse provinces and regions.

Carney's Response

Carney's victory speech directly addressed Trump's threats, a stark contrast to previous Canadian political discourse. This direct confrontation resonated with the concerns of many Canadians and received a supportive reaction from Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission. The author concludes by suggesting that the current American political climate might paradoxically strengthen ties between the remaining liberal democracies.

Sign up for a free account and get the following:
  • Save articles and sync them across your devices
  • Get a digest of the latest premium articles in your inbox twice a week, personalized to you (Coming soon).
  • Get access to our AI features