Zugersee: Schwyzer Kantonsrat lehnt Belüftung ab

Lake Zug Aeration Rejected

The Schwyz cantonal council rejected a proposal to financially participate in the aeration project for Lake Zug, aimed at reducing phosphate levels. The decision, supported by the SVP and FDP parties, failed by a vote of 51 to 43.

Financial and Efficacy Concerns

The project, costing approximately 12 million Swiss francs initially, plus annual operational costs of 109,000 francs for Schwyz, faced opposition not only on financial grounds but also due to concerns about its effectiveness. Opponents argued that aeration is unnecessary and that the lake will recover naturally.

Government and Opposition Views

The Schwyz government expressed disappointment, with the environmental director, Sandro Patieno, criticizing the council's decision-making style. The government argued that the project was essential for improving lake health, while opponents argued against the cost and potential inefficacy.

Key Players and Arguments

• Government: Advocated for aeration, stressing the necessity of restoring lake health.
• SVP and FDP: Opposed aeration due to concerns about effectiveness and cost.
• Environmental director: Criticized the political process and the rejection of expert advice.

The rejection leaves the future of the Lake Zug aeration project uncertain.