Raphael Enthoven critically examines French President Emmanuel Macron's pledge to recognize a Palestinian state. He raises concerns about the ambiguity surrounding the borders, leadership, and the role of Hamas. He argues that Hamas' actions have severely undermined the possibility of a viable Palestinian state in the near future.
Enthoven points out the paradox of how good intentions can inadvertently legitimize violence. He suggests that recognizing a Palestinian state after the October 7th attacks might inadvertently validate Hamas' violent actions as a means to achieve its goals. This, he argues, could portray the October 7th attacks as a consequence of an unjust situation rather than an isolated act of terror.
However, Enthoven concludes by suggesting a potential positive outcome. If Macron's initiative leads to broader regional recognition of Israel by countries like Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, or Turkey, it could be considered a strategic masterstroke. This would involve a significant shift in regional dynamics and relationships.